Trusted Partners
A sealed earcup pressurises the air against your eardrum, which is where sub-bass weight and outside-noise rejection come from, and it also creates a small resonant box that colours the midrange. Opening the back removes the box and the pressure at the same time. That is the entire bargain, and no amount of driver quality changes it.
For a South African desk in a shared house or a flat near a busy road, the honest answer is often a closed pair for the lounge and an open pair for quiet evening sessions. Where the room is under control, an open design is the cheaper route to convincing positional audio, because the effect comes from the acoustics rather than from processing that has to be licensed and switched on.